No Contract, No Case: The Five Documents Every Michigan Business Needs Before Something Goes Wrong
Most business disputes do not begin with fraud.
They rarely start with someone intentionally trying to deceive another person. More often, disputes arise when two people believe they agreed on the same thing, only to discover later that they interpreted the conversation very differently.
A relationship that once worked smoothly can change. Circumstances evolve. People leave. Businesses grow. Ownership changes. Suddenly, a verbal understanding that once seemed perfectly clear becomes the subject of disagreement.
That is what contracts are for.
Contracts are not a sign of distrust. They are a tool for creating clarity. They establish expectations, define responsibilities, and provide a framework for resolving disagreements before they become costly disputes.
In our experience, businesses that end up in litigation often share one common characteristic: somewhere in their history, there was a conversation where there should have been a document.
Here are five agreements every Michigan business should have in place.
The Operating Agreement or Shareholder Agreement: The Rules Your Business Runs On
Many business owners form an entity, obtain an EIN, open a bank account, and immediately begin operating. The governing documents are either never drafted or remain generic templates downloaded during the formation process.
That is a mistake.
An operating agreement or shareholder agreement establishes how your business will function when difficult decisions arise. It addresses issues such as voting rights, ownership transfers, distributions, dispute resolution, and what happens if an owner dies, becomes disabled, wants to leave, or disagrees with the other owners.
Consider two business partners who own a company equally. One wants to expand by bringing in a new partner and taking on debt. The other disagrees. Without a governing agreement that outlines decision-making authority and deadlock procedures, both owners may find themselves unable to move forward while facing expensive litigation.
A well-drafted agreement establishes who can make important decisions, how disputes will be resolved, when owners can transfer their interests, and what happens if an owner dies, becomes disabled, divorces, or leaves the company.
If your business does not have a customized agreement, Michigan’s default statutes will apply. Those rules were not written specifically for your business.
The Independent Contractor Agreement: Ownership Requires Documentation
Many business owners are surprised to learn that paying for work does not automatically mean they own it.
Under U.S. copyright law, independent contractors generally own the intellectual property they create unless ownership is transferred through a written agreement.
This issue frequently arises with software development, website design, marketing materials, photography, branding assets, and training materials.
Imagine investing significant resources into developing a custom software platform, only to discover that the outside developer legally owns the underlying code because no written assignment exists.
Without a properly drafted agreement, your company may not own the very assets it depends on.
A strong independent contractor agreement clearly defines the scope of work, payment terms, confidentiality obligations, and, most importantly, ownership of intellectual property created during the engagement.
The intellectual property assignment provision is often the most important clause in the entire agreement.
The Customer Agreement or Terms and Conditions: Define Expectations Early
Business disputes often arise not because either side acted improperly, but because expectations were never clearly defined.
A vague description such as “comprehensive services” can mean entirely different things to different parties.
Without a written agreement establishing scope, deliverables, pricing, and limitations of liability, even successful business relationships can deteriorate quickly.
A properly drafted customer agreement clearly defines what services are included, what services are excluded, when additional fees apply, how and when payment is due, and how disputes will be resolved if they arise.
These provisions do not exist to protect businesses from bad clients. They exist to ensure both parties understand the relationship from the outset.
Clarity prevents disputes.
The Non-Disclosure Agreement: Protect What Makes Your Business Valuable
For many companies, their most valuable assets are not physical.
They are confidential processes, pricing models, customer information, proprietary systems, and strategic plans.
Michigan law does provide protection for trade secrets, but those protections often depend on whether the business took reasonable steps to maintain confidentiality.
Sharing sensitive information without an NDA can significantly weaken your ability to protect that information later.
A properly drafted NDA defines what information is confidential, how that information may be used, who may access it, how long confidentiality obligations last, and what remedies are available if the agreement is breached.
Strong confidentiality agreements provide more than documentation. They provide leverage when sensitive information is misused.
Once confidential information becomes public, the damage may already be done.
The Buy-Sell Agreement: Plan for the Events No One Wants to Discuss
No business owner enjoys discussing death, disability, divorce, or departure.
Yet these events occur regularly, and businesses that fail to plan for them often face significant disruption.
A buy-sell agreement functions much like a prenuptial agreement for business owners. It establishes what happens when ownership changes unexpectedly.
Without one, surviving owners may suddenly find themselves in business with an owner’s estate, former spouses, or other unintended parties.
A comprehensive buy-sell agreement identifies triggering events, establishes how ownership interests will be valued, determines who has the right or obligation to purchase those interests, and sets a timeline for completing the transition.
These conversations may feel uncomfortable while the business is growing.
They become far more expensive when postponed.
What These Five Agreements Have in Common
None of these documents are especially complicated.
More importantly, every one of them costs significantly less to prepare proactively than to litigate after a dispute arises.
Commercial litigation can easily cost tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees, not including lost management time, business disruption, and missed opportunities.
A properly drafted set of foundational agreements represents a relatively modest investment when compared to the cost of resolving preventable disputes.
The math is straightforward.
One Final Thought: Templates Are Not a Substitute for Legal Advice
Online templates are often better than having no agreement at all.
However, generic forms are not designed for your specific business, ownership structure, industry, or goals. They frequently omit critical provisions and may fail to comply with Michigan law.
Poorly drafted contracts often create ambiguity, and ambiguity frequently leads to litigation.
The purpose of a contract is to eliminate uncertainty, not create more of it.
Is Your Business Properly Protected?
Many business owners assume they have the documents they need, only to discover significant gaps when problems arise.
A contract audit can help identify those gaps before they become expensive. The best time to address legal risk is before a dispute occurs.
That conversation starts now.
Mavacy Law. On time, on budget, before you even have to ask.
Author



